Labor Market Forecasts:  How Accurate Are They?

April 27, 2022

Many community colleges and other higher education institutions use labor market forecasts to inform decisions on academic programs, faculty hiring, and facilities investments.  In particular, the Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) forecast growth rates are often used to identify potential new programs and those that merit further investment.  How accurate are these forecasts?  

When BLS Becomes BS

To answer this question, we started with the BLS 2012 forecasts by Standard Occupation Code (SOC).  These forecasts estimated growth rates and total employment for 2022 in approximately 850 SOCs.  We used the BLS rates to estimate employment from 2012 to 2019, ending before the pandemic.  This was a period of slow, stable growth, with no major terrorist attacks, pandemics, or recessions; this stability should have made predictions, including the BLS forecasts, more accurate. 

As illustrated below, only 8% of the BLS forecast growth rates were roughly right, that is, within 25% of the actual growth rate.  82% of the forecasts were off by 50% or more.




To be fair, the analysis did not show that BLS estimates of the number of employees in an occupation were off by 50% or more.  Let’s work through an illustration:  In a SOC with 1.0 million people employed, let’s assume that BLS forecast 2% growth and that the actual growth rate was 0%.  At a 2% forecast growth rate, 2019 employment would be 1.15 million, and actual employment would remain at 1.0 million (at 0% growth).  While the percentage growth rate was off by 100% (2% vs. 0%), the predicted number of people employed differs only by 0.15 million or 15%.  


The Dismal Science Problem

As I mentioned in my last blog, we should not blame the BLS for forecasting errors.  They have recently updated their forecasting methodology, and it may be better than it was – but we won’t know for ten years.  State forecasts are likely to be more error-prone since the national data smooths out more volatile state-level data (think oil booms and busts in Oklahoma).  In any case, I believe the U.S. economy is both complex and chaotic; it is impossible to make accurate 10-year forecasts, even in normal times, like the period from 2012 to 2019.  When we add in unpredictable events like wars, terrorist attacks, recessions, and pandemics, our vision of the future becomes cloudy indeed.


Making Accurate Predictions

That said, I think some areas will be more predictable than others, but I have not tested this hypothesis.  For example, demographic trends are relatively predictable.  The number of people who will be 60 in 20 years can be predicted with reasonable accuracy since we know how many people are now 40.  As a result, fields like healthcare that are linked to an aging population are likely to be more predictable over the long term.  However, even these fields may suffer enormous disruptions, like the pandemic, that belie the forecasts.

How is a community college, or any other higher education institution, supposed to make long-term investments in growing fields if growth rates are so uncertain?  Please stay tuned.  I’ll get to that soon.


Robert Atkins


Bob led Gray’s entry into the education industry and the development of Gray’s proprietary industry databases and service offerings. He has worked directly with many of Gray’s education clients, consulting with CEOs and CMOs on business strategy, pricing, location selection, curricular efficiency, and program strategy.

Related Posts

When Bad News Is Good News: Cyber Breaches Drive Demand For Cybersecurity Programs

Discover how recent cyberattacks are shaping cybersecurity programs at academic institutions. Are there enough interested students, and will graduates find jobs in this field? Explore the surge in cybersecurity graduates, enrollment trends, and employment opportunities, revealing a promising landscape for both students and higher education institutions.

The Artists Are Not Starving: How Arts Programs Profit Students and Schools

Can arts programs lead to prosperous careers? We dissect recent data that challenges the “starving artist” stereotype. Explore the resilient growth of visual and performing arts enrollments post-pandemic, the diverse paths graduates take, and surprising employment outcomes. Discover why arts education is not just surviving but thriving. 

A Shot of Perspective on the Nursing Shortage: Insights into Employer Demand

Uncover the surprising trends shaping the future of nursing with Gray’s Head of Research, Elaine Rowles! Delve into the intriguing interplay between enrollment, job postings, and salaries for RNs and LPNs. Despite certain declines, the demand for nurses remains strong, leaving a profound impact on nursing programs and the overall healthcare landscape. Explore how educators and employers are actively shaping the future of nursing. Plus, get valuable insights into the recent data on nursing jobs and its implications for higher education.

About Us
closeup photo of

Gray Associates, Inc. is a software and services firm focused on higher education. We help education clients develop fact-based institutional and marketing strategies that maximize outcomes for students, the school, and its constituencies.

Let’s Socialize

Popular Post
Subscribe to Our Blog

Don’t miss the latest research and insights from Gray Associates