What Is an Academic Program Evaluation Process?

October 11, 2022

An academic program evaluation process is data-informed, transparent, collaborative, and intensive when done correctly.It combines data with institutional judgment. Participants bring knowledge of their domain and the institutional mission. Establishing this process at your college or university reveals current and potential new programs that merit investment to increase enrollment and revenue and serve diverse demographic groups. This process also reduces internal obstacles to implementation, speeds up time-to-market, and optimizes ROI by focusing investment on high-potential opportunities.

Important Points to Know Before Getting Started

A successful program evaluation process is multi-faceted and involves stakeholders across the institution:

  • Top-down or “closed-door” decision-making can impede the development of successful programs.
  • Comprehensive data is crucial and should include academics, markets, and program margins.
  • Good program decisions take more than numbers. Success comes from the institutional knowledge and experiences each team member brings to the table.
  • Ongoing, systematic reviews will strengthen your academic program portfolio and more likely to sustain vitality during downturns or unexpected crises.
  • All programs have life cycles. Even “tried and true” general education programs need course updates to keep them healthy.

The Key Elements of Academic Program Evaluation

Program evaluation should include the four key elements that drive successful programs as well as the people and processes to balance a successful program portfolio. Programs must:

  • Honor the mission of the institution, and serve the needs of students and the community at large
  • Adhere to academic standards and meet institutional accreditation requirements
  • Align with market demand, including student demand, employer needs, and competition by degree level
  • Be margin-conscious – not all programs need to be contribution-positive, but the overall portfolio needs to be financially balanced

Wrapped around the key elements of academic programs are the people and processes that drive successful program evaluation:

  • People: Include academic and institutional leaders in decision-making.
  • Process: Bring the people together in workshops to review all current and potential new programs. Facilitate the discussion and reach an agreement on program decisions.

Having a strong analytical foundation and a clear, inclusive process for program evaluation leads to better decisions, strengthens relationships across the campus, and is consistent with the principles of shared governance.

Robert Atkins


Bob led Gray’s entry into the education industry and the development of Gray’s proprietary industry databases and service offerings. He has worked directly with many of Gray’s education clients, consulting with CEOs and CMOs on business strategy, pricing, location selection, curricular efficiency, and program strategy.

Related Posts

Stars Are Aligning for Astrology Programs

Looking for a unique and popular program that’s perfect for students? Look no further than Astrology! With growing interest in wellness, psychology, and astronomy, this program is on the rise across all award levels. From strong completion rates to skyrocketing enrollment and trending Google searches, Astrology is a program that’s truly aligning with the stars.

Start, Stop, or Grow: A Master Class on Academic Program Evaluation and Management

Improve your institution’s academic program portfolio with Gray’s free Master Class series led by experienced higher-education decision-makers. This four-part series covers data analysis, AI and machine learning, program evaluation, and student success integration. Stay ahead of the competition and ensure success by evaluating programs based on mission, academics, markets, and margins.

Boost Enrollment and Prepare Your Students for a Hot Job Market

With completions trending up, enrollment on the rise, and an 87% growth rate in Google searches for marketing programs, now is the time to start or expand your institution’s Marketing program. Gray’s latest analysis shows why careers in marketing are booming and why institutions looking to grow their enrollment and improve student employment options should consider offering a bachelor’s program in Marketing.

About Us
closeup photo of

Gray Associates, Inc. is a software and services firm focused on higher education. We help education clients develop fact-based institutional and marketing strategies that maximize outcomes for students, the school, and its constituencies.

Let’s Socialize

Popular Post
Subscribe to Our Blog

Don’t miss the latest research and insights from Gray Associates